My analysis of Eminem vs. other MC's
 

You clearly don't know a thing about Hip-Hop if you think Eminem is "head and shoulders" above Mos Def, Jay-Z, and Nas. He is in the same class with them, but Mos Def for sure is better; Jay-Z and Nas are slightly better. This whole Eminem thing is like rating Duke in the top 5 of undergrad schools (over Dartmouth and Chicago) because Duke is a non-ivy league school, and there's a clamor to make sure everyone knows it is just as good as the Ivy league. But the commentators get over-zealous and put it two spots behind Harvard, and in the same class as Penn, MIT, and Stanford.

Mos def is better , Jay-z aint better , Nas is slightly better ,

Eminem Sucks....

This thread sucks...

No shit. Why is this moron talking about college rankings??

hes goin to harvard...not devry...didnt you know?

where did you go to college?
have you accepted the lord jesus christ?

jus fuckin..um hes white...hes talented but
ummm hes white...which isnt a bad thing
and he stands out.

man this dude is stupid....how the fucck u gonna compare..eminem, MOSDEF, jayz and nas??
and i capatilite MosDef 4 a reason....his style is waaayy different that others...i think mabe this dude is a newcomer 2 hip-hop...and 4 the record..eminem is way overrated, and i aint hatin cuz hes white either...atmosphere is another white emcee who is just fire man...in my opinion atmosphere is leagues ahead of em

I ain't no Eminem lover or anything, I hardly listen to him that much, but just admit that he has a shitload of talent, a shitload of ability and right now, he and 50 are two of the hottest artists at the moment! (P.S, i don't like 50, his voice goes right through me!)

There are alot of Talented underground artists, but if they got deals, started goin about in Mercs etc... Would You Still Listen To Them, And Say That They Are Tight As Fuck!

Eminem's new shit is horrible especailly last album.......first was the bomb

dude eminem is tha shit hands down this white kid is flippin da script and makin his money.......notta damn thang wrong wit it

It's been said once and it'll be said a million more times, Em is ill but he fell off A LOT. All of his new material doesn't compare with his old ones. He used to be a lyrical demon, now I consider him as one of the regular rappers out right now, just slighty above average.

I AGREE
 

I agree

an i think eminem right now is the best
you think hes not as good as before you gotta here his freestyles
and the new shit that hes making wit obie trice
and shit on the conspiracy theory

i think he needs to start taking drugs again. thats when all his creative shit comes out. slim shady lp was his best.

that album was shit.......