Eminem before Slim Shady LP
 

When Do you think he was better?

Infinite & Slim Shady EP
or
Slim Shady LP, Marshall Mathers LP, Eminem Show

I feel that he was much more true back in the day and i also liked his flow better. He kinda sounds like he has hiccups when he raps.

He went from Infinite - "I never packed a tool or acted cool, it wasn't practical
I'd rather led a tactful, tractical, track for your fancy"

to

"Im goin to get my gun." on D12 world.
That's gay.

I think he was better when he did infinite and slim shady lp because thats when he was hungry to get into the game and prove himself

he was better on infinite,but hes still raw

MMPL and SSLP are still tight, unlike most i actually liked the eminem show too... D12 world sucks...

Man i got evidence im neva dence and ive been clever ever sence
My residence was hesitent to do some shit that represents
THE MO

classic, how can you say he wasnt the best

But MMLP

Know why i say these things, cause ladys screams,
keep creepin in shadys dreams, and the way thing seem,
i shouldnt have to pay these shrinks,
these 80 g's, a week to say the same things twice...

also classic

SSLP

I feel like im walkin a tight rope without a circus net,
poppin percaset, im a nervous wreck, i deserve respect,
but i work a sweat, for this worthless check,
im bout to burst this tech, at somebody to reverse the set...

classic

Eminem Show...

Never was a thug, just infatuated with guns,
Never was a gangsta till i graduated to one,
and got the rep of a villian, for weapon concillan,
took the image of a thug, kept shit appealin...

Classic

yoo i think em.. has been tight for a long time.. i dont like when he tries to drop that funny shit.. like my band! and the real slim shady.. i like when he gets real angry and shit thats when he is his best

he was better on infinite and slim shady ep...

...nuff said...

Tha Slim Shady Lp. is tha definition of raw i mean you could tell that tha dude was thirsty for more and i think thats one of tha reasons why he got so big so fast...

Marshall Mathers LP was tight, but so was Slim shady, hard choice buts its all good yo

yea eminem is up there among some of the best, but Tupac is better =)..

he's always been good but it just took him awhile to get respect

Will the Real Slim Shady please come back... he was best back then..

no doubt no doubt.. but he aint the best, cause there so many out there.. to be honest hes prolly not even to me, my top 3.. just gonna drop out some names.. busta is bannanas, biggy, pac, Hov, im really feeling meth, theres alot of talent out there.. but slim is def among them =)

^^most def^^

the old slim shady was the shit i didnt like the Eminem Show was gay i think

eminem show sucked the most.