Best Overall QB in the NFL
 

Poll and explain why.

In my opinion, it is Donavann McNabb. He has speed, arm power, and accuracy. All those things make up a great QB. Vick can run, but dont have the accuracy that McNabb has.

i partially agree with u on Mcnabb...but i think it is a toss up
between him Mcnair..and manning
not to take anything from any of the others Qb's
bret favre has had another favre type season..nothin that really stands out...

I wish i could put vick up there with the rest but his injury kept him from even having the chance to compete at 100%...
but i think tom brady should def. be on this list as well...

word, he is fast, and he can throw good.

Bledsoe, Brady, And Mirer Aren't Up There Why? Ok, I'm Just Jokin About Mirer, But Not About Brady And Bledsoe.

Anyways... I Think It's Close Between McNabb, McNair, And Brady.

hmm

I like Peyton Manning, he's been doing his thing for years and getting slept on... although he does have Harrison....

Mcnabb is second best IMO

Axe E. Um, edit out Brooks and Kitna, and put Brady and Bledsoe. I forgot about them.

brady

clutchest quaterback
wins the most

yea gonna have to go wit brady as well..
but mcnair is the toughest... he even plays well while injured
peyton manning is the smartest..makes pretty good pre-snap reads...

but i think brady is having a better all around year...

thats a hard question cause their isnt any stand out QBs in the NFL right now alot of good ones but none like farve in his prime, or elway, marino, young, montana.

manning is the best technique wise and is one of the better passers and a good leader, but he cant win for shit in the playoffs

mcnabb is prett good overall but isnt the best at anything he does

favre is past his prime, or i would pick him cause he is one of the best alltime. but today he isnt as good.

mcnair is the tuffest QB and is dependable, very underrated QB

cullpepper is good but i dont think he is anything special his stats mostley come form his suporting cast.

trent green, he is good, but anyone could look good with vermial as the coach and the other D focused on holmes. and a TE like gonzo to dump the ball off to cause most LBs cant cover a TE like tony.

gannon had a few great years, but this year was blah, and great years with the WRs he had arent had to have, then you add in chalie garner who is one of the best reciving RBs in the NFL now he is old and washed up

kitna - no one good year doesnt make you the best. but he does have telent and i have seen it since he was in seatle

vick he can run better then any QB but he hasnt learned to pass yet. he is the most over rated play in the NFL

garcia - is inconsistant and as a 49er fan i got tired of it this year, he is to jumpy and doesnt know how to stay in the pocket, and he has a weak arm, but he is also up with mcnair as one of the tuffest QBs in the NFL

i probabley have to go with manning even though he cant win in the playoffs i feel he is the best overall QB, right now, either him or mcnair but there is really no QB that stands out as the best to me right now.

^dayum, C knows his shit there.....

manning no doubt but he chokes in the play offs and no no no vick can throw he has a fucking cannon his recievers are shit. if he had a team like gannon had last year he would won the super bowl. how man teams beat greenbay in the play offs?

vick no doubt......hasn't learned to pass yet?....I think he has...
^^
will be a legend if he is not plagued by injuries all career.......

David Becham easily..dayme