Quick and Short...

( 40% ) -- Punches - EyE
( 25% ) -- Flow - Spit
( 15% ) -- Personals - EyE
( 05% ) -- Multies - Neither (both were lacking)
( 05% ) -- Structure - Spit
( 05% ) -- Originality - EyE
( 05% ) -- Vocab - EyE


Overall i think that some of spits lines were a bit played, but a few of EyE's were too. But EyE came with harder punches, well thought out personals, and over-all more original and better verse.
EyE's downfall was his structure, flow just a little off, and multies.
Spists downfall was he lacked originality, some lines were played, lacked multies, and needed harder punches and a few more personals.

My Vote = EyE Que

..