Marshall Mathers LP mightve been a classic, but it had a 2 crap songs (Drug Ballad, The Real Slim Shady) and seemed a bit too gimmicky. It also had some annoying skits.

The Eminem Show was too commercial, boring and repetitive. It wasn't interesting like his first two, and his rhymes went worse too. Production was worse too cos of a lack of Dr. Dre. The only thing elevated on The Eminem Show was his flow.

Stillmatic wasnt a classic cos of some bad hooks and one HORRIBLE song. Some of the production was sub-par too.. otherwise it was dope.

Black Album was unorganized, but still dope. Two bad songs as well (Change Clothes, Dirt Off Your Shoulder).