Nice battle, i'll break it down.

Punches- Underrated (he took this by far with more distinct punches that landed better)
Personals- Underrated (simply found more creative ways other than playing off the name)
Style- Cata (you have a lot of style man, your verse was distinctly your own)
multis- Cata (Lots of multis compared to Under)
Structure- Tie (not the most important category, both acceptable structures)
Flow- Tie (I rapped both with no problem at all)

Win- UnderRated, won more important categories, good battle

__________________
tobacco pipe smoker
escobar, your life is over
justify the righteous nova
bullets flew out his right shoulder