this was a close battle....so i broke it down like this..

smiley

flow- 8/10
structure- 9/10
punches- 7/10
personals- 5/10
creativity- 4/10
wordplay- 6/10
39/60

BTK

flow- 5/10
structure-6/10
punches-4/10
personals-7/10
creativity-6/10
wordplay-5/10
33/60

vote-smiley-39/60