lil rip: talked a lot about how hardcore his crew is and not much about his lyrical skill or his opponent.

d.j em sce: didn't punch very hard, but had the more intelligent disses overall. Took some wind out of his own sails by admitting an earlier defeat, but seemed to recover from that and get down to business. "harder than last night's erection" sounded better when Phife said it on Beats, Rhymes and Life, but that's probably coincidence -- a lot of cats probably use that analogy.

Bottom line -- vote goes to d.j em sce.