This was a close battle.

punches- Buch
opener- Ven
mettas- Buch
flow- Ven
personals- BUch
wordplay- tought but i'ma give it to Ven
originality- Buch
complexity- Buch
overall- Tough call but I think I'm a give this to Buch, if Ven had a few more punches and personals it woulda gone the other way