Rookie's stuff was not as weak as folk make it out to be. He focused way too much on the rhyme scheme, but at least he showed he can do that, and he squeezed one punchline out of it that got my attention: the "dermatologist / poppin it" thing.

That said, however, Accomplishment clearly took this one with an unrelenting rain of punches. Not all of 'em connected (the Tyson / Bitin' ears thing is beyond played-out), but there's no doubt he put down the superior battle verse.