This was a close battle both of yall came hard with solid lines and punches.

Punches-Black Thief's hit harder, but Shadows Edge had come clever ones they just needed to be better worded.
Creativity- Shadows edge (ya had creativity but it just needs to flow more)
Origional-Shadow's edge (punches seemed new)
Mulits- Black Thief
Flow-Black Thief (read through it easier, cause better use of mulit's)
Opener- Black Thief (wasn't feel'n the whole minimum wage thing)
Closer- Black Thief (Liked the coral reef but the two punches before that wasn't hurt'n Black Thief)

All in all Black Thief takes this one.