I wasn't a fan of either verses really. Not to say that they weren't good, just my personal preference.
Jay-Dogg came too simplistic. I mean, look at something like this:
"this bitch thinks he can shoot/
mother fuckers still in his birthday suit/"
Wtf?
popa doc needs to check his spelling but he at least was using Jay_dogg's name against him. He actually had personals as opposed to Jay-Dogg who spit generic.
Vote is for popa doc.
http://community.rapbattles.com/showthread.php?t=123621