bleh........its obvious to see forsaken one......and i dont want to leave an explained vote!!!.......but oh well here goes

UnTouched-........bad cartoon effect turnout......the glow on the guy ruins it as well
The bground is way wack.......you had an idea with the ruins, but then you put them wack ass brushes on the right side.......that really had nothing to do with anything, so i dont see the use of them......and im not feelin the black and white theme, nor the font....

Forsaken- i like yours more because yours looks better......the color adds alot of dimension to it.....the font is overused, but it works ok with the signature......you didnt overload the signature with brushes.....and you kept it nice and smooth
and yours just overall appears better than untouched.......

ill put it like this........yours actually looks good to look at it, in some sense......

Tip for the day: Adding effects to the main picture (person or of the sort) such as Outer Glow or Inner Shadow is usually a very bad idea......it often fucks up the sig.....
so dont do it no more

the only one that can ever be good........and have some sort of good effect, is drop shadow......but dont go ape shit with it.......Effects on Pictures = No - No

that concludes todays lesson.....

__________________