hmmmm....ya'll both did a pretty good job wit dis topic, not da easiest....

V3-
good use of the videogame character, font works well wit da sig an i like the green....
doesnt look like you cut anything though, looks like you threw text onto a pic then added some brushing and a color layer....although simple, it looks good....

Distilled-
you obviously spent more time on yo sig, but the layer above the backround is awful, it honestly blows the entire sig....
its one too dark and two just so random, it doesnt really go with any other part of the sig?? not feelin the soldier being faded out either though....
you did a good job wit your text as well, probably a bit better than V3's....

really when you break it down, its about a tie in the categories.......
like i said, obviously Distilled spent more time on his sig, but i actually like V3's more which gets him mah vote....
v/ Version Three
good effort from both though.....

__________________