Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Crazy Hades
Too bad Harry Potter's the only books you've read, TeamOne. Oh, man, her villian is comparable to Hitler! How exotic! How original! Not really. Stop being so amazed at such ridiculously un-subtle symbolism. Harry is not Jesus. Read Orson Scott Card's essay on the matter.
There are legions of books out there that are better than Harry Potter. They touch on more subjects, and touch them better, and touch on more adult subjects, and they have better writing. Because Harry Potter has the shitty writing, especially The Deathly Hallows. Half of the book are the characters not knowing what to do next; a quarter of it is a deus ex machina that allows them to run into every single character from the past; almost a quarter of it is ridiculous relationship plotlines; and the rest is Voldemort being stupid. Not to mention that 100% of it reads like a crappy fanfic, and hardly matches up to Goblet of Fire, a book which in itself was rather stupid looking in the long run.
Read better books. Order I recommend reading:
|
The Harry Potter series are fictional novels meant for pleasure reading, not meant to be a thematic masterpiece of epic proportions. Lmao. Omg Hitlers a bad man and so is Voldemort! I see the connection! Wow!
JK Rowling might not be the most
technically skilled writer of all time, but she did manage to come up with a unique world that has kept millions of readers hooked because of it's interesting nature, well designed storylines, and real life parallels. You can't dispute her ingenius ability to create her own world and tie everything together so that it makes sense (in the context of her world). Her storytelling ability has fascinated millions of readers, I don't know why you are disputing her ability to do so. As far as technically skilled writers, she isn't even up there, but as far as storytelling ability, she is clearly one of the best of all time. Sometimes she is held back a little by her character development, but for the most part, that is decent. In any case, her main plotlines are always very well thought out. Bottom Line: who cares about the bullshit you're talking about? And that TeamOne is talking about? I read to be entertained. And I think most writers are given way too much credit when it comes to "making comparisons to God etc" -- their comparisons aren't even intentional most of the time, it just comes down to the fact that these kind of themes are a part of human nature. I remember an interview where Robert Frost corrected some scholar who was saying his poetry was symbolic of this or that. Then he said, "no, I wrote it - it's not".