1. Live charges you to use your own internet connection to play against other people.

Explain how that makes any sense what so ever.

2. Especially considering games like Resistance 2, Killzone 2, Warhawk, and Socom all have Dedicated Servers.

Xbox 360's flagship title, Gears of War 2?, doesn't have one single dedicated server.

3. Let me put this in even more laments terms:

Paying 50$ a year for Live when PSN is available, is like paying 50$ a year for air, when ...free air is available.

Sure 50$ is cheap as hell, but do you really want to pay for something you don't have to pay for?

__________________