WORDPLAY:neither had good wordplay if i had to give it to someone it would be crazy cause he had some
FLOW:Fan got this...came off the lines better
MULTIS:Crazy took this had more combos towards the end
PUNCHES:I think that fan took it...he had more punches
COMEDIC VALUE:Fan took this one i liked these

"you been dun, now its time for you to meet big pun"
and
"I'm Shady you aftermath, the present and you're tha past
I'll put a dent in your career, like the gaurd that put a dent in Bow Wow's ass......"

so my vote goes to fan