Ok i don't usually read topical, but heres my vote....

Vocab from both was tight, not to complex but not to simple, i was feeling pledges mroe, you noe connected more with it sorta thing, sounded like it was wrote from experience, and as the saying go "the story depends on the teller"... Anywayz flow was about even Pledge jus' took that aswell...

So

Flow = Pledge
Consistency = Even
Vocab = Even

Prti close but i'd give this one to Pledge cause it sounded more deep....
My bad if i didn't vote properly cause i don't do this often...

My Vote = Pledge

Pce