opener - retained
closer - retained...spit that was probably the worst one ive seen to date
punches - spit...this was best bar Herb needs to Grow, got you Wet to Help Water Ya
U have to be Male to get Sonned, so I guess I Daughtered Ya!

retained this was your best bars see $pit' was in Black Tie...but got rejected from the Execs..
..its the same fuckin crew..and this tryout verse's a Wreck
how du expect to be Recruited..with a 10 loss, Mocked Margin?
..Controlled the battle so much..Spit keeps callin me Sergeant

all in all retained had way more original punches that were personals so harder hitting
personals - retained...explained it above
wordplay - both were equal in this
vocab - spit
originality - retained
overal - retained...good spit from both of you but retained won with punch personals