i thought htis as a pretty close battle, both came harder in different catagories...but i gotta say i think the newb took this one...heres Dev's breakdown....

punches=Mc
flow=bren
structure=bren[Mc ya lines are stretched to fuck]
creativity=tie
enjoyment=bren
opener=Mc
closer=bren
wordplay=Mc

Mc took this if it was on punches,,but i dont only go on that....i jus felt that ya had too many played lines......so my vote goes to bren...pZ......