im not gonna say that anyone is right or wrong
i been using pro tools for a little while on pc and a mbox2 and ive come across the problem of running out of tracks that i can hear. we did one track inwhich about 5 people were on it
plus a hook and a over dub. so math wise

3 to 4 tracks a verse

3 tracks a hook

1 over dub

5 people

so thats

20 tracks for 5 verses
3 tracks for the hook
(i loop so its not a deal of making a new track for each hook section, just for those who dont know that)

pluse the overdub

when i got to about 28 tracks

the 28th track went dim and i didnt hear it in the mix i had to switch the mixer on to get it to work. but a guy i know who runs a prominent studio in chicago uses logic and he told me he never has this problem. soooooo i prefer pro tools cause i like pro tools but i hear TONS of good shit about Logic and Garage Band as well

I use Pro Tools LE 7..0.1
M BOX 2
GT66 PRE AMP
GT66 CONDENSOR MIC
etc.

__________________

EMPTY HAND RECORDS/STRAY SHOT ENT.