a systematical understanding of the emotions at hand due to the situation at hand wouldn't prove a thing unless you understood the systematical switching of the emotions of the person..
in other words YES this hypothetical situation is subjective but it's more or less a lesson about ethics rather than one about diagnosis.
So it is with this that I fully conclude that with the systematization of this hypothetical situation concept, I would only like to keep you with this final opinion on it: a hypothetical situation in part with a characterization of a probable person's attitude is flawed unless there is also prior characterization of what is to be expected of said person; Some people would be happy to have this hypothetical situation happen to them, because they might have something else in mind.
So understanding the emotional basis of a certain few amount of actions isn't doing the complete job (by still leaving out emotions like Happiness) and furthermore understanding the basis of a storyline hypothesis only leads to further hypothesis.
so simple brother goodbye now