Text-Hass( Cleaner flows better)
Color- Hass (Used more then one color)
BG- Neither (Both lacked detail)
Blending- Hass
Flow- Hass

Explaination... I believe Hass took this only because what you tried to do tech did not come out very well. If you would have spend more time on your little circle thing and blended your text better you would have had a better chance. Both sigs could of been better but because that one part is crazy choppy it threw off the whole sig.