when i saw mad dogg's punch i see some attempt at something deep.. but i see that same attempt in LP's.. tie here. now onto wordplay.

fluid on the brain (Flooded is exempt. Sorry, flooding an online site with money was not connected to your insult. Next time, connect it. Otherwise, it's pointless.)
vs.
slobbing-foaming. foaming-dog. gay-togas.

LP clearly took it with wordplay amount and complexity.

general insult - Madd Dog: you're retarded. LP: you're gay.
useless information without language here; MD used a metaphor, "like", which is hardly acceptable even in audio street battles these days. It's gotta be real sick to use a 'like' punch, so that sickness can cushion it's downfall with your choice of using that specific word.. LP's had implication with the toga party.

I just don't see any way, by evaluation of the choice of word inclusion and structure, that LP does not take this.

vote - LPMNDCTE.