These kinds of speculations are so dumb. Logically, it all boils down to one question.

Is God all-powerful?

If you think he isn't, then there you go. If you think he is, then God's just a dick. Hands down. If he made humans imperfect on purpose, he's a dick for making humans imperfect, because there is no reason to do so. If he's not intervening for whatever reason, he's a dick because he could but he won't.