Class Sic's vote was disqualified because he basically just listed the verses and below it had put a 2 line explanation and then listed the scores out of 10. The only unique thing was him putting "under and Charles do not rhyme". We have always disqualified for putting xx/10 and the explanations did not say how to improve or what was wrong with the verse. Telling someone to work on their structure or punchlines doesn't tell them what is wrong with them and can make it appear like someone is just pasting the feedback from one battle to the next.

__________________
.